Understanding Mobile Phone Laws in NSW

Legal Definition and Prohibitions

Under the NSW Road Rules 2014, Rule 300, it is illegal to use a mobile phone while driving unless the vehicle is parked. The rule strictly prohibits holding a phone in hand while driving, even if the vehicle is stationary at traffic lights or in traffic. Drivers are not permitted to use their phones for texting, making or receiving calls, browsing the internet, or accessing social media while behind the wheel.

The rule aims to reduce driver distraction and improve road safety, ensuring that mobile phone use is limited to legally acceptable situations, such as when the vehicle is parked and not in motion.

‍

Penalties for Mobile Phone Offences

The penalties for mobile phone offences in NSW are significant. Drivers caught using their mobile phones illegally face a $353.00 fine and 5 demerit points, which increases to $469.00 if the offence occurs in a school zone. During double demerit periods, the points can double, leading to even harsher consequences.

Accumulating demerit points can lead to a licence suspension, particularly for provisional drivers or those nearing their point limit. Reaching or exceeding the demerit point threshold may result in mandatory suspensions, impacting your ability to drive. Staying informed and compliant with mobile phone laws is crucial to avoid these penalties.

‍

Defences Under Regulation 300 of the Road Rules 2014

Legal Defences

Under Regulation 300 of the Road Rules 2014, drivers may raise certain legal defences when charged with a mobile phone offence. These can include:

• Self-defence: Using the phone in response to a genuine threat.
• Duress: Acting under coercion or unlawful pressure to use the phone.
• Necessity: Using the phone to prevent harm in an emergency situation.

These defences require strong evidence and are only applicable in specific situations where the use of the phone was unavoidable and necessary.

‍

Statutory Exceptions to the Offence

There are statutory exceptions that permit mobile phone use while driving under certain conditions. These include:

• Using the Phone as a Driver’s Aid: If the phone is securely mounted in a cradle and used for navigation (e.g. GPS).
• Emergency Situations: Using the phone to contact emergency services, such as police, fire, or ambulance.
• Hands-free Use: Drivers are permitted to make or receive calls if the phone is connected via Bluetooth or speaker, as long as they do not touch the phone while driving.

These exceptions ensure that drivers can safely and legally use their phones under controlled circumstances without violating the law.

‍

What Must the Prosecution Prove?

To secure a conviction for a mobile phone offence under Regulation 300 of the Road Rules 2014, the prosecution must prove several key elements, including:

• The Driver Was Using the Phone: The prosecution must demonstrate that the driver was actively using the mobile phone, which includes holding, texting, calling, browsing, or any other prohibited action.
• The Driver was Driving or Stationary in Traffic: It must be shown that the driver was operating the vehicle or stationery (e.g. at traffic lights) but not parked.
• It Was Not an Emergency or Legally Permissible Use: The prosecution must establish that the phone use was not for an emergency (such as contacting emergency services) or within the legal expectations, like using the phone as a GPS or in hands-free mode.

‍

‍

Strategies to Get Out of a Mobile Phone Fine

Challenging the Evidence

Insufficient Proof

One strategy for contesting a mobile phone fine is to review the evidence provided by the authorities. This may include photos, videos from traffic cameras, or testimony from police officers. If the evidence is unclear or incomplete, it can be argued that there is insufficient proof to definitively show that you were using your phone illegally.

By demonstrating the lack of clear evidence, you can challenge the validity of the charge.

‍

Camera or Officer Error

Another possible defence is to point out potential errors by the camera system or attending officer. Common errors include misidentification (e.g. mistaking another object for a phone) or technical faults with detection cameras that may lead to false readings. For example, mobile phone detection cameras may malfunction or capture incorrect data. By demonstrating these errors, either through expert testimony or technical evidence, you can challenge the accuracy of the evidence used against you and potentially have the fine dismissed.

‍

Special Circumstances

Emergencies

An emergency is a situation where immediate action is required to prevent harm to yourself or others. Under Regulation 300, using a mobile phone in an emergency can be a valid defence. Examples include calling emergency services due to a medical issue, an accident, or imminent danger on the road. To successfully use this defence, it is essential to provide documentation, such as phone records showing the call to emergency services, or witness statements verifying the situation.

‍

Medical Conditions

Certain medical conditions may necessitate the use of a phone while driving. For example, a person with a chronic health issue may need to communicate with healthcare providers urgently. To rely on this defence, it is crucial to provide medical evidence, such as a letter from a doctor detailing the condition, its potential impact, and why phone use was necessary. This documentation should clearly explain how the condition required immediate action and phone use.

‍

The Contesting Process

Reviewing the Infringement Notice

The first step in contesting a mobile phone fine is to carefully review the infringement notice. Look for any errors or inconsistencies that could serve as grounds for contesting the fine. Key aspects to check include:

• Date and Time of the Alleged Fffence: Ensure that this information is accurate and that you were driving at the stated time.
• Location Details: Verify that the location mentioned aligns with where you were driving.
• Vehicle Identification: Ensure that your vehicle’s registration and details are correct.
• Specific Offence Details: Check whether the alleged offence accurately reflects your actions.

‍

Gathering Evidence

Witness Statements

Obtaining witness statements from passengers or bystanders can be a crucial part of contesting a mobile phone fine. These people can provide testimony confirming that you were not using your phone illegally. Passengers in the vehicle at the time can affirm that the phone was not in use, or that it was being used legally. Statements from bystanders, especially if they are neutral third parties, can further support your case.

‍

Phone Records

Phone records can be powerful evidence in contesting a mobile phone offence. By providing your phone’s call and message logs, you can demonstrate that no calls, messages, or data use occurred at the time of the alleged offence. This helps establish that the phone was not being used illegally while driving, potentially leading to a dismissal of the fine.

‍

Submitting a Review Request

When contesting a mobile phone fine, submitting a review request to the issuing authority is an essential step. The request should be clear, professional, and well-documented. The request should include:

• Personal Information: Include your full name, address, contact details, and infringement notice number.
• Details of the Offence: State the date, time, and location of the alleged offence.
• Grounds for the Review: Clearly explain why you believe the fine should be reviewed, such as incorrect details of the infringement notice or evidence proving you were not using the phone illegally.
• Supporting Evidence: Attach relevant documents, such as witness statements, phone records, or photos.
• Conclusion: Politely request the fine be dismissed or reviewed.

‍

Going to Court

Preparing Your Case

When contesting a mobile phone fine in court, thorough preparation is essential. Start by gathering all necessary documents, such as phone records, witness statements, and any photos or videos that support your case. It is important to organise these documents clearly, as they will form the basis of your defence. You should also review the legal provisions under Regulation 300 of the Road Rules 2014, ensuring that you understand the charges and can build a defence around errors or exceptions that apply.

In court, you have two main options:

• Pleading Guilty: If you admit to the offence but have mitigating circumstances (e.g. emergency use or a genuine mistake), the court may reduce the penalty.
• Pleading Not Guilty: If you believe the charge is unjustified, you can present your evidence to dispute the fine. Your argument must demonstrate that either the prosecution’s evidence is flawed or your phone use was lawful under an exception.

‍

What to Expect in Court

When contesting a mobile phone offence in court, the process generally follows a procedure. This includes:

• Presenting Evidence: You will have the opportunity to present your case, starting with the submission of all relevant evidence. This may include phone records, witness statements, and any other documentation that supports your defence. Your lawyer will ensure your evidence is well-organised and easy to reference in the hearing.
• Responding to Magistrate Questions: If you have a lawyer, they will respond to all questions on your behalf. However, if you do not, the Magistrate may ask you questions about the incident to clarify your version of events.
• The Hearing: The prosecution will present their evidence against you. This may include police officer testimonies or camera footage. You will then have the opportunity to challenge this evidence.
• Outcome: After hearing from both parties, the Magistrate will deliver a decision. If found not guilty, the fine will be dismissed. If found guilty, the Magistrate will issue a penalty.

‍

Costs of Contesting a Fine

When deciding to contest a mobile phone fine in court, it is important to consider the potential costs involved. Electing to go to court can incur a range of expenses, including legal fees if you have a lawyer represent you. Even if you self-represent, there may still be costs related to preparing your case, such as obtaining copies of phone records or evidence.

If you are found guilty, the court may impose additional fines, which could exceed the original penalty. Furthermore, you may be required to pay court costs, which include administrative fees associated with the hearing.

‍

Alternative Options and Financial Hardship

Options for Financial Hardship

For people who choose not to contest a mobile phone fine but are facing financial hardship, there are several options available.

• Payment Plans: You can apply for a payment plan, allowing you to pay the fine in instalments over time.
• ‍Extensions: If you need more time to pay, you may request an extension from Revenue NSW to delay the payment due to date.
• ‍Write-off Applications: In cases of severe financial hardship, you can apply for a write-off of the fine. This requires proof of your financial situation and is typically only approved in exceptional cases.

‍

Section 10 Dismissals

A Section 10 dismissal offers the possibility of avoiding a conviction, even if you plead guilty to the offence. Under Section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999, the court has the discretion to dismiss the charge without recording a conviction if there are mitigating factors, such as a clean driving record, good character, or the circumstances of the offence.

Faraj Defence Lawyers can assist in applying for a Section 10 dismissal by presenting a compelling case that highlights your personal circumstances, emphasising any factors that may encourage the court to grant this leniency. This can help avoid fines, demerit points, and the lasting impact of a conviction.

‍

Preventative Measures & Tips

To avoid mobile phone fines and stay compliant with the law, some practical tips include:

• Set Up a Hands-free System: Use Bluetooth or a speaker system that allows you to make and receive calls without touching your phone
• Use a Cradle: Securely mount your phone in a cradle to legally use it as a driver’s aid, such as a GPS.
• Turn Off Your Phone: To eliminate temptation, consider turning off your phone or setting it to airplane mode while driving.
• Install Blocking Apps: Use apps that block incoming calls or messages while driving to reduce distractions and prevent illegal use.

‍

Seeking Legal Advice for Your Mobile Phone Fine?

Hiring a lawyer when contesting a mobile phone fine offers several key advantages. Lawyers with expertise in traffic law understand the complexities of the legal system and can identify potential defences that you may not be aware of. Lawyers have experience in contesting fines, from reviewing the evidence to challenging the accuracy of charges or presenting a compelling case for leniency.

A lawyer can also help reduce penalties, such as arguing for a Section 10 dismissal, which may result in no conviction or fines. Professional knowledge can increase your chances of success, making legal representation a valuable option.

‍

How Faraj Defence Lawyers Can Help

At Faraj Defence Lawyers, we have extensive experience in successfully handling mobile phone offence cases. Our legal team is well-versed in traffic laws and has a proven track record of reducing penalties, securing section 10 dismissals, and helping clients retain their licences. If you are facing a mobile fine that could result in losing your licence, it is crucial to seek legal advice.

Our Defence Lawyers can assess your case, provide guidance, and work to increase your chances of keeping your licence.